+- Punaweb Forum (http://punaweb.org/forum)
+-- Forum: Punaweb Forums (http://punaweb.org/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Punatalk (http://punaweb.org/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: New Punaweb Posting Policy (/showthread.php?tid=2471)
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - kani-lehua - 08-02-2008
quote:
Originally posted by Rob Tucker
kani-lehua, If you don't know and I don't notice I'm betting someone else probably will.
But I'm not going to invite vigilante post counters. I'm hoping I don't uncork more problems
that I might solve.
Punaweb moderator
**holds up hand and counts 1,2,3,4,5**
all pau [^]
"chaos reigns within.
reflect, repent and reboot.
order shall return."
microsoft error message with haiku poetry
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - frossie - 08-02-2008
I may be coming into this late, but I am wondering what this limit is trying to achieve? If it is the only way to achieve something important, then perhaps we can loook (I can help) at some forum software than enforces it automatically. If the purpose is to avoid tit-for-tat he-said she-said threads, then perhaps moderating the offending threads is more fair to people who generally keep their noses clean.
By the way Damon, was that you at the rally with the cute boy? We should have been wearing nametags. I was the ha'ole with the blond kid. I'll keen an eye on your blog
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - Guest - 08-02-2008
Frossie -
Yes that was me and my little opihi.
I think I've found my answer to the 5 post's per day limit:
I'm only going to start new topics and will respond to threads on my own blog.... Emailing the starter of the thread off the board to let them know that I have responded to there Punaweb thread on my blog
People can feel free to comment over there... and I will be discussing other things then just Puna related stuff.[
]3 or is that 4 for today already?
P.S. Rob let me know that paying members of FoPF can post as many times as they want in the "Members" only section of Punaweb.
-------
My new blog
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - Jon - 08-02-2008
Well its been fun...
I guess my kind are not longer welcome.
Transplanted Texan
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - missydog1 - 08-02-2008
hi Rob, as we all know it's your site to do as you think best. I see what you're wanting to achieve, a balance between voices, which is good. For you not to have to play hall monitor, also good!
But, and this is feedback as a poster, and in no way a "you SHOULD" -- having a five post limit severely dampens an interchange of information, and it also quashes the impulse to simply post in admiration, support, thanks, frivolity, to make a quip ... it makes me weigh every post like it has to count for something ...
What would I like to see? A limit on new topics started by any one person in the Punaweb forum. One a day or not more than two.
No post count limit in nonclassified, building and gardening.
Maybe a post limit in the Punaweb forum ... but I think it will almost suppress dialogue between posters to stay with five.
Personally, if I had a number one request of other posters, it would be to ask them to stop analyzing other posters' lifestyle, personality, quirks, etc.. based on their posts. I think it is rather rude and hurtful to play internet psychoanalyst, and I have yet to see it help restore harmony.
I belong to another site where they had a lot of interpersonal problems until they formalized guidelines that went something like -- if you disagree, disagree with my ideas and my facts, but don't tell me to shut up (free speech rule) and don't make it personal (no attacking other posters rule).
Just my two cents. [
]
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - Guest - 08-02-2008
A post starts a thread or topic.
A reply is a response to a post/topic or it can be a response to a reply.
Surely, Rob does not mean to limit replies.
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - Guest - 08-02-2008
That would be like limiting the number customers to a store.
In this case the Punaweb-Mart store includes products like
Meat = Ideas
Fruits = Thoughts
Vegetables = Concepts
Dairy = Questions
Canned Processed Ham = Answers
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - missydog1 - 08-02-2008
Last night people were counting replies in the post limit in the discussion. From what Rob said, it would be work for him to play post cop. Topic count is easy if you're around the site much.
oh, and I apologize to Rob for posting discussion as I just re-read the top post which I had read last night and not remembered he asked for suggestions to be emailed.
Although it looks like my post brought out that we are not all on the same page with what post count means. I expect Rob will clarify when he sees this.
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - Guest - 08-02-2008
quote:
Originally posted by KathyH
hi Rob, as we all know it's your site to do as you think best. I see what you're wanting to achieve, a balance between voices, which is good. For you not to have to play hall monitor, also good!
But, and this is feedback as a poster, and in no way a "you SHOULD" -- having a five post limit severely dampens an interchange of information, and it also quashes the impulse to simply post in admiration, support, thanks, frivolity, to make a quip ... it makes me weigh every post like it has to count for something ...
What would I like to see? A limit on new topics started by any one person in the Punaweb forum. One a day or not more than two.
No post count limit in nonclassified, building and gardening.
Maybe a post limit in the Punaweb forum ... but I think it will almost suppress dialogue between posters to stay with five.
Personally, if I had a number one request of other posters, it would be to ask them to stop analyzing other posters' lifestyle, personality, quirks, etc.. based on their posts. I think it is rather rude and hurtful to play internet psychoanalyst, and I have yet to see it help restore harmony.
I belong to another site where they had a lot of interpersonal problems until they formalized guidelines that went something like -- if you disagree, disagree with my ideas and my facts, but don't tell me to shut up (free speech rule) and don't make it personal (no attacking other posters rule).
Just my two cents. [
AGREED[8D]
Question... if we delete a post before we post a new post does that count as a zero post?[:o)]
I've seen over
]4.5
*edit* wow you guys are flooring me with your support off line and in emails.
Mahalo
-------
My new blog
RE: New Punaweb Posting Policy - John S. Rabi - 08-02-2008
I think the software can be set easily to limit the postings to any number, so there is no need for Rob to play a cop. I personally never count my posts and still don't get to five, though I use the direct e-mail function and e-mail people regularly.
Aloha,
John S. Rabi, GM,ARB,BFT,CM,CBR,FHS,PB,RB
808.989.1314
http://www.JohnRabi.com
Typically Tropical Properties
"The Next Level of Service!"