Thread Rating:
  • 2 Vote(s) - 3 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
How We Lost Our New [Big Island] Home To Trump's Illegal Tariffs
Durian Fiend - Google AI says the cost of shipping a tiny home from China to Honolulu is 10-15K for freight alone. So, given these numbers are we to believe that Will's home cost only about $5-10K initially? And why wasn't he required to pay all fees upfront before it shipped, like the folks in the video above?

So back on page 3, I noted "a comparable model as the one shown starts at ~$4k in China (see pic #2)" which has a near identical picture as the one used for the Civil Beat article.

The unit costs ~$4k in China, add in a mid-range shipping estimate of $12k and you get $16k assessed value when it hits the Hilo docks. Given the 2024 tariff rate of ~20% you get $3.2k in tariffs and fees so $16k + $3.2k = ~$20k that Will would have paid up front back in the fall of 2024. When the unit finally arrived in ~June or later 2025, there are now an addition $10k in tariffs and fees as the Country of Origin tariffs for China and/or the Steel tariffs had increased. From my experience, Will would likely have had to put aside ~$6k for prep, trucking, craning, and setup at his site, so when you have a budget of ~$26k, a surprise and unpredictable $10k fee is clearly enough to torpedo the project.

Not sure why this is so hard for some to understand, but the math is mathing and, much like the tariffs, it all adds up.
Reply
The unit costs ~$4k in China, add in a mid-range shipping estimate of $12k and you get $16k assessed value when it hits the Hilo docks. Given the 2024 tariff rate of ~20% you get $3.2k in tariffs and fees so $16k + $3.2k = ~$20k that Will would have paid up front back in the fall of 2024.
------------
Tariffs are not calculated on the shipping costs. They are calculated on the sales price. A 20% tariff on $4k is $800.
Reply
leilanidude - Tariffs are not calculated on the shipping costs. They are calculated on the sales price. A 20% tariff on $4k is $800.

Ah, you're correct in that the U.S. uses a FOB (Free on Board) calculation verses a CIF (Cost, Insurance, and Freight) calculation as is used in the UK and EU, which I was more familiar with. (there's a reason people hire specialists to handle the complexities of importation)
https://www.millenniumcargo.com/how-tari...ing-costs/

So $4k prefab + a higher $15k shipping + $800 tariff = ~$20k. Will still could have had his unit for ~$20k based on the 2024 tariffs, before the Country of Origin tariffs and Steel tariffs were jacked up to historic highs in 2025 based on the whims of one person.
https://www.piie.com/research/piie-chart...date-chart
Reply
These charts show so much winning. Too bad it's not us.
Reply
But wait, there's more... if anyone wants to look at a visualization of the tariffs before the massive increases, after them, and now, either overall or by sectors, along with highlighting specific tariffs like those on China and on Steel that come into play when you try to obtain a metal prefab structure like Will did:
https://unctad.org/topic/trade-analysis/...-dashboard
Reply
We don’t know for certain whether Will lost his home to tariffs, or how, but the same Illegal tariffs discussed in this thread have affected almost everyone in Hawaii, consumers and local businesses. Too bad we live in an era of unaccountable actions.

A survey of Hawaiʻi businesses revealed tariffs and trade policies have affected 86% of local businesses in the last year. The Hawaiʻi Pacific Export Council, along with the Retail Merchants of Hawaiʻi, conducted the survey, and 45% of the businesses surveyed said they were expecting profitability declines of more than 10%.

Storefront in Hilo - closed
Successful recycling project on Big Island - hanging on

https://www.hawaiipublicradio.org/local-...ing-prices
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)