11-22-2015, 03:48 PM
Originally posted by terracore
wouldn't that control group consist of EVERYBODY who has ever had a blood test with Dengue that didn't drink papaya leaf juice?
Unfortunately, no. There are known trends in the disease progression including a drop and then a recovery in blood cell counts. To show that papaya leaf juice is having any effect you need side-by-side control group to ensure the other factors (disease strain, supportive care, etc) are all the same.
Here's a chart derived from the WHO guides on dengue showing the general disease progression - notice the rise in platelets around day 6-7, the same as seen in the 12 patients given papaya leaf juice?
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:...orized.svg
Considering that papaya leaf juice is free to most of us, and if there are no downsides, why not try it?
IF there are no downsides, why not indeed? Many in Malaysia, where dengue outbreaks include hundreds of fatalities, have come to a similar conclusion.
http://says.com/my/lifestyle/can-papaya-...ngue-fever
The 2013 study linked at the end of the article had 290 participants with a control group and provides some real evidence of increased platelet count for those treated with papaya leaf juice.
wouldn't that control group consist of EVERYBODY who has ever had a blood test with Dengue that didn't drink papaya leaf juice?
Unfortunately, no. There are known trends in the disease progression including a drop and then a recovery in blood cell counts. To show that papaya leaf juice is having any effect you need side-by-side control group to ensure the other factors (disease strain, supportive care, etc) are all the same.
Here's a chart derived from the WHO guides on dengue showing the general disease progression - notice the rise in platelets around day 6-7, the same as seen in the 12 patients given papaya leaf juice?
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:...orized.svg
Considering that papaya leaf juice is free to most of us, and if there are no downsides, why not try it?
IF there are no downsides, why not indeed? Many in Malaysia, where dengue outbreaks include hundreds of fatalities, have come to a similar conclusion.
http://says.com/my/lifestyle/can-papaya-...ngue-fever
The 2013 study linked at the end of the article had 290 participants with a control group and provides some real evidence of increased platelet count for those treated with papaya leaf juice.