07-28-2012, 07:38 AM
I'm assuming you have looked at your property survey to verify where the tree stands? Firstly start by talking to your insurance agent as the most qualified expert in this matter.
I had a similar situation where the neighbor wanted me to cut down my tree incase it fell. My reply was maybe we should cut all of the trees down then, argggg (showing no signs of obvious rot or disease). However some trees like my maple tree can be rotting from the inside and a periodic full trim is the best way to insure the life and safety of the tree.
You are generally liable if you neglect to take care of the tree on your property. If the tree were to be obviously diseased or rotting it should be removed to protect yourself. An "act of god" such as a lightening strike or a storm that blows it over onto your neighbors land should be covered by their insurance. If you check w/ your agent you'll probably get the same story and that should be your next step.
If you want to save the tree from your neighbor's axe you'll have to weigh the value of the tree against the benefit of keeping your neighbor happy. If the tree is healthy then you could offer to let them remove the tree at their expense but if a problem tree maybe offer to remove at half the expense base on a written agreement and estimate by a qualified and insured tree removal expert.
I had a similar situation where the neighbor wanted me to cut down my tree incase it fell. My reply was maybe we should cut all of the trees down then, argggg (showing no signs of obvious rot or disease). However some trees like my maple tree can be rotting from the inside and a periodic full trim is the best way to insure the life and safety of the tree.
You are generally liable if you neglect to take care of the tree on your property. If the tree were to be obviously diseased or rotting it should be removed to protect yourself. An "act of god" such as a lightening strike or a storm that blows it over onto your neighbors land should be covered by their insurance. If you check w/ your agent you'll probably get the same story and that should be your next step.
If you want to save the tree from your neighbor's axe you'll have to weigh the value of the tree against the benefit of keeping your neighbor happy. If the tree is healthy then you could offer to let them remove the tree at their expense but if a problem tree maybe offer to remove at half the expense base on a written agreement and estimate by a qualified and insured tree removal expert.