10-20-2006, 12:26 PM
Chili - you might as well flip a coin. Both have advantages/disadvantages that have been thoughtfully presented by others here. Personally I like P&P, but I could see sites and/or structures where concrete would be just as good an option. WELL constructed is the key to being happy with whatever you choose. If I was going with concrete, I would be very picky about who I had do my slab. If Catherine D's (Cat) SO was available to do it, I would choose him because I know he does 1st class work.