09-06-2008, 08:52 AM
quote:
Originally posted by DickWilson
No Bob, I wasn't there.
I Rest My Case!
Hello Bob,
I assume, by reading your posts that you’re a litigious fellow. I think the one thing you may have missed, at least from my post, is I believe Kathy and John in their reports. You seem to feel that Mr. Stenzel is innocent until proven guilty and in a legal setting you would be right but in a real life setting of “he said she said” one has to generally weigh the stories and their sources and draw a conclusion.
This thread was on its way out when Mr. Stensel decide to come on here and call Kathy a liar. He has yet to tell his story or, I assume, to contact Kathy. Kathy appears to me to be pretty smart and I'm sure she has considered the consequences of posting in an open forum. With that said, I think it's important to point out the fact that she has not backed away from her original post in the least actually to the contrary she is now threatening legal action.
You may feel like her story is all here say and not worthy of recognition and maybe in a legal setting you'd be right but this is PW. I think this is the type of incident that PW was created for. I don't think a long standing member of PW should be afraid to come on here and warn people about a contractor that she had problems with. Do you? I don't think Dick wants to find out this guy's nature with the guy cussing out his wife.. let alone someone having to clean up the blood.
Again, all we have to work with is the two individuals’ stories. Mr. Stenzel has found his way here in as much a he has now come on and started name calling with out any explanation. Which kinda parallels Kathy's original story. If anything, I think if he's a stand up guy this would be the place to start proving it and calling Kathy a liar, without following up, speaks volumes.
Blessings,
dave
"It doesn't mean that much to me.. to mean that much to you." Neil Young
Originally posted by DickWilson
No Bob, I wasn't there.
I Rest My Case!
Hello Bob,
I assume, by reading your posts that you’re a litigious fellow. I think the one thing you may have missed, at least from my post, is I believe Kathy and John in their reports. You seem to feel that Mr. Stenzel is innocent until proven guilty and in a legal setting you would be right but in a real life setting of “he said she said” one has to generally weigh the stories and their sources and draw a conclusion.
This thread was on its way out when Mr. Stensel decide to come on here and call Kathy a liar. He has yet to tell his story or, I assume, to contact Kathy. Kathy appears to me to be pretty smart and I'm sure she has considered the consequences of posting in an open forum. With that said, I think it's important to point out the fact that she has not backed away from her original post in the least actually to the contrary she is now threatening legal action.
You may feel like her story is all here say and not worthy of recognition and maybe in a legal setting you'd be right but this is PW. I think this is the type of incident that PW was created for. I don't think a long standing member of PW should be afraid to come on here and warn people about a contractor that she had problems with. Do you? I don't think Dick wants to find out this guy's nature with the guy cussing out his wife.. let alone someone having to clean up the blood.
Again, all we have to work with is the two individuals’ stories. Mr. Stenzel has found his way here in as much a he has now come on and started name calling with out any explanation. Which kinda parallels Kathy's original story. If anything, I think if he's a stand up guy this would be the place to start proving it and calling Kathy a liar, without following up, speaks volumes.
Blessings,
dave
"It doesn't mean that much to me.. to mean that much to you." Neil Young
Blessings,
dave
"It doesn't mean that much to me.. to mean that much to you." Neil Young
dave
"It doesn't mean that much to me.. to mean that much to you." Neil Young