quote:
Originally posted by Punatic007
quote:
Originally posted by Chas
I hadn't been on Punaweb for a while and saw this topic, and it was already a couple of pages long. Even before I started reading it I thought to myself, "OK, there will be one request for contributions and then a whole lot of people adamant about why you SHOULDN'T help these kids".
... Just as I thought! [8D]
Chas I don't know if you live here or not or are aware that the Big Isle was, if not still is, the most welfare generous state in the USA. It's impossible to go hungry here unless you are on drugs or insanely irresponsible. Then the moral dilemma comes in....do I enable the parents and mask or gloss over a situation that should be investigated or do I say no this is wrong?
I don't know but as a world traveler I can tell you our poverty is affluence compared to the poverty of developing nations. In other words no comparison. If a child is not being fed, it's just a matter of time until Child Protective Services swoops down and rescues the child. Be grateful that your tax dollars are being used in such a effective way. God bless America because this type of effective social welfare is very rare.
As I've stated many times, no I don't live there (wait for it... then why are you on this forum?)
I'm well aware of the welfare system and it's deficiencies but I guess I don't understand the logic of, "Sorry kids, I have to teach your parents a lesson".
And I’m pretty sure these kids won’t understand, “Well you may think YOU have it bad, but compared to kids in other countries…..” reminds me of my parents telling me to eat all my dinner because kids were starving in China.
Maybe we could instead say "free food for kids" then when the kids get there, give them a class on how to apply for assistance or turn in their parents for neglecting them?
My point is, no matter how "wrong" it is for the way someone wants to help a bad situation, I don't see this effort being made by the Pahoa Boys and Girls Club or Lee's request for support as being a bad thing.
I'm also amazed at how people would rather spend their time criticizing other's efforts then actively coming up with and executing what they think is a better solution.
By the way, where are all of you on Rob’s Santa’s Workshop topic? Surely that has to be bad for them as well right?