Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Papaya Seeds & Earthworms
#1
I know this should be in Gardening but, has anyone heard of this?
Grandson on Oahu had a paper from school looking for compost materials from their homes for a class project. No papaya seeds please it said. Because they cause earthworms to be sterile. Well, now I've heard everything. Just found this web site and sure enough that is what it said. I wondered where all my earthworms went.
http://www.waikikiworm.com/5ww1boxbin.html
Reply
#2
Are there any foods that are poisonous to worms?
The only food waste that seem to do damage to worms are papaya SEEDS. They do not break down and leach into the bin some substance that renders our worms temporarily sterile. Papaya skin and flesh is OK. It's my opinion that you should feed an intense food like coffee grounds only in moderation - once a week maybe, not every day. A little common sense goes a long way when it comes to feeding. For example, a lemon mixed in with a variety of food wastes is OK, but an entire bin-load of lemons is just too much acid at once. If you have a question about a particular food, try a small amount and see what happens.


When I met with C., the director of Hogwarts' Center for Public Service, a few weeks prior to our worm bin installation, she provided me with a copy of the instructions that the Center places on its worm bin, offering guidelines on what/what not to put into the bin. The following dire caveat caught my eye:

1. Do NOT add the following:
• Papaya seeds: makes us sterile!

While I would've never thought to have placed papaya seeds in the bin anyway, since they're hard objects that'd be slow to biodegrade, naturally, I wondered whether the warning was true or apocryphal. So I Googled "papaya seeds worm sterility" and discovered the probable source. Mindy Jaffe, the owner of Waikiki Worm and the most well-known of Hawaii's worm suppliers and vermicompost educators, warns against feeding worms papaya seeds as "they will render them temporarily sterile". Hmm. I decided to pursue my research and attempt to dredge up some reliable scientific sources that definitively linked papaya seeds to worm sterility. If this was true, I wanted to know what the underlying cause was…it sure seemed questionable. After all, papaya seeds are definitely edible—would consuming papaya seed dressing, for example, render humans sterile, temporary or otherwise?

After doing an Internet search, I discovered the following:

1. Apparently, in some cultures, e.g. Indian Ayurvedic medicine, papaya (not just the seeds, but the fruit itself) is traditionally used in indigenous and naturopathic medicine as a vermifuge: a means for expelling intestinal worms (no mention of earthworms here, nor of the supposed sterilizing effects). Also, papaya apparently has anti-nematodal properties as well.

2. The following rationales were provided as to why papaya could be an effective vermifuge:
-Papain, the active enzyme in papaya, eats away at the protective outer cuticle of worms. I can't speak for intestinal worms, but given the number of people who've successfully fed papaya shells to their composters, who've subsequently thrived, the theory sounds questionable. Apparently, the effect is lessened in the presence of digestive juices, which might account for why the worms don't seem to be suffering ill effects.
-Papaya seeds contain a chemical, benzyl isothiocyanate, that is an anthelminthic, that is, a medicine of use against intestinal worms. As the papaya matures, the level of this chemical decreases in the fruit's flesh, but increases in the seeds. Alas, like papain, it's also apparently unstable in the presence of digestive juices, so it couldn't be particularly effective as such.

google really is your friend! Smile I guess if you got intestinal worms maybe eating papaya seeds might help?

Reply
#3
Howdy folks,
FYI,,Nematode's are a type of worm. Certain types can be a big problem if they get into your potato patch or into your favorite mushroom bin,,,,,not to ention any that can invade your intestinal system!
Reply
#4
Ericlp - no chance they make coqui's sterile too?? [:p]
Reply
#5
Hey Cat-sorta good news-I think the little fire ants are driving the Coqui out of my yard.I have noticed a huge decrease of Coqui in the areas most infested with ants.

Too bad I can't go out in the yard anymore.
Reply
#6
I think I'd take Coqui over LFA any day.

It's why I bought a small lot this time on the big island. LFA sucks.

[Sad!] Nothing worse then trying to trim back the coconut trees and having the little bastards rain down on you. 3 acres with LFA = NO FUN!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)