Posts: 2,377
Threads: 124
Joined: Jun 2009
One of the people overcome by the gas complained of not being able to get a full breath. This is interesting considering the following regarding sulphur dioxide inhalation.
" Biochemical and biomedical roles
Sulfur dioxide is toxic in large amounts. It or its conjugate base bisulfite is produced biologically as an intermediate in both sulfate-reducing organisms and in sulfur-oxidizing bacteria, as well. The role of sulfur dioxide in mammalian biology is not yet well understood. [19] Sulfur dioxide blocks nerve signals from the pulmonary stretch receptors and abolishes the Hering–Breuer inflation reflex."
From
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sulfur_dioxide
And what the hering-breuer inflation reflex is described in the below link.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hering%E2%8...uer_reflex
Posts: 785
Threads: 6
Joined: Apr 2012
[quote]Originally posted by Wao nahele kane
One of the people overcome by the gas complained of not being able to get a full breath. This is interesting considering the following regarding sulphur dioxide inhalation.
" Biochemical and biomedical roles
Sulfur dioxide is toxic in large amounts. It or its conjugate base bisulfite is produced biologically as an intermediate in both sulfate-reducing organisms and in sulfur-oxidizing bacteria, as well. The role of sulfur dioxide in mammalian biology is not yet well understood. [19] Sulfur dioxide blocks nerve signals from the pulmonary stretch receptors and abolishes the Hering–Breuer inflation reflex."
This is unfortunately typical of the complete nonsense that is being peddled here... What, in any way, does sulfur dioxide have to do with the discussion? The steam released by PGV didn't, doesn't, won't contain sulfur dioxide - pretty much ever. The completely bogus claims made on the occupy Hawaii videos are, in fact, more consistent with sulfur dioxide exposure - but the sulfur gas present in PGV steam is hydrogen sulfide - completely different compound, completely different physiological action, completely different symptoms of exposure. Just another exercise in eco-extortion. "Oh, I feel sick, please deposit cash here..."
Posts: 2,377
Threads: 124
Joined: Jun 2009
Geochem... stop making an ass of yourself. Hydrogen sulphide becomes sulphur dioxide in the atmosphere but you would have known that had you any credibility in your handle. Look it up and stop pretending to know about something you clearly haven't even taken the time to read about, let alone have any sort of knowledge about. Its a FACT.
Posts: 2,244
Threads: 396
Joined: Nov 2011
quote:
Originally posted by Wao nahele kane
Geochem... stop making an ass of yourself. Hydrogen sulphide becomes sulphur dioxide in the atmosphere but you would have known that had you any credibility in your handle. Look it up and stop pretending to know about something you clearly haven't even taken the time to read about, let alone have any sort of knowledge about. Its a FACT.
Um, your comment is being made to a scientist who has
facts, and has more experience in geothermal than most of us put together. Now, I would suggest geochem is not the one who is making ass.
Frankly, your verve, in not only this topic, needs tempering.
JMO.
Posts: 526
Threads: 11
Joined: Oct 2006
A little research reveals that you have to burn hydrogen sulfide with oxygen (produce a blue flame) in order to produce sulphur dioxide. Not what happened at PGV so sulfur dioxide is irrelevant here.
Posts: 785
Threads: 6
Joined: Apr 2012
quote:
Originally posted by Wao nahele kane
Geochem... stop making an ass of yourself. Hydrogen sulphide becomes sulphur dioxide in the atmosphere but you would have known that had you any credibility in your handle. Look it up and stop pretending to know about something you clearly haven't even taken the time to read about, let alone have any sort of knowledge about. Its a FACT.
If you had bothered to gain even a little knowledge of the chemistry of hydrogen sulfide you would know that that conversion takes hours to days - so, given the wind speeds at the time the plant tripped, by the time whatever hydrogen sulfide discharged by PGV was converted to sulfur dioxide, I would reckon that it would be somewhere off South Point. No FACT, just more fertilizer.
Posts: 2,377
Threads: 124
Joined: Jun 2009
Geochem,
You appear to be hung upon and befuddled by my comments regarding so2. If you note further back in the thread I was questioning the actual confinement of the well pressure within the system as it is partly reliant upon the rock structure itself at the actual well cavity region. Any pressure within such a cavity is subject to any faults located within the cavity and therefore would act as an escape route for some of the pressure within the cavity. Such a breach, minor or major could possibly induce more rapid expulsion of SO2 from within the surrounding geological structure. Since naturally occurring h2s is subject to so2 and extreme heat the volcanic conditions naturally breakdown both gasses to a great magnitude when not exposed to rapid expulsion conditions. When the plant undergoes an emergency release of pressure its at that time the well cavity pressure is greatest and any natural faults within the cavity then could become a greater source of rapid expulsion for surrounding SO2 pockets. My initial entry on the So2 matter revolves around the plausibility of such a scenario. To outright assume there are no natural fractures in the structure 'bout the well cavity and no pressure from the well cavity is influencing the surrounding natural volcanic events is foolish at minimum. Furthermore this assumption that I have not taken into account H2S is a misconception. Of the two gasses H2S is the more dangerous because of the necessity for it to be at relatively hazardous levels before noticing its odor. So2 on the other hand is for more noticeable at lower concentrations. So my curiosity is in the reports of the smell accompanied by the possibility of naturally tied in fractures to the well cavity. I would appreciate for moment that you got off your assumption horse and put that big brain of yours into possible explanations for the victims claims other than assuming they are all stupid ignorant people just trying to manipulate the system.
Posts: 1,217
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2014
Blah blah blah. Meanwhile not one single medically verified case of geothermal poisoning as a result of the storm related shutdown.
Posts: 563
Threads: 60
Joined: Jun 2013
Started a new thread for this but since it is relevant to our discussion I have posted it in this thread as well - maybe any comments would be better in the new thread?
http://www.hawaiicounty.gov/storage/depa...652683.pdf
So this SOE was declared August 7, the day after the hurricane.
Mayor's Proclamation From August 7, 2014
State of Emergency exists on the Hawaii Island, Effective 6:00 AM Thursday, 08/07/2014 and continuing thereon for 60 days or until further act.
State of Emergency exists on the Hawaii Island, Effective 6:00 AM Thursday, 08/07/2014 and continuing thereon for 60 days or until further act.
http://www.hawaiicounty.gov/active-alerts/
I posted this link as I found it and what you will notice is that the
SOE is mentioned twice in a row of an otherwise chronological order.
What this means to me is that their had been a previous post most likely an UNABRIDGED warning about PGV and the release of dangerous gases that had occurred on the night of Aug 6, has been deleted. (better check that link now!)
As well we are still under that SOE, meaning normal Hawaii state laws instituted by elected officials are in suspension (not saying that "normal" laws are not being adhered to).
Posts: 563
Threads: 60
Joined: Jun 2013
quote:
Originally posted by lavalava
Blah blah blah. Meanwhile not one single medically verified case of geothermal poisoning as a result of the storm related shutdown.
You don't live here so the impact of this event is remote to you and as a result your inclination to "trash talk" seems unqualified at best.
